Skip to content
February 28, 2007

Bloggers/Forum Owners Immune against Commenters

I wish we had something similar to this here in the Philippines:

In Universal Communication Systems v. Lycos, a company who had allegedly been victimized by defamatory statements on a message board regarding the value of its stock sued Lycos, which operated the board. The message board allowed users to post comments with minimal moderation, and no one from Lycos was responsible for the allegedly defamatory statements.

Examining the impact of Sec. 230 on this case, the court noted that “Congress intended that, within broad limits, message board operators would not be held responsible for the postings made by others on that board,” adding that allowing bloggers and message board operators to be sued for the statements of commenters on their sites would have an “obvious chilling effect” on speech. Accordingly, the court dismissed the complaint against Lycos.

Then my life would have been much, much less chaotic and exasperating. I wouldn’t have also dug deeper into my pocket.

Credits to ACSBlog, via Andy Beal.

Written by yuga

Abe is the founder and publisher of YugaTech. You Can follow him on Twitter @abeolandres.

Follow me on Twitter or add me up on Facebook.


9 Responses to “Bloggers/Forum Owners Immune against Commenters”

  1. Nick
    Twitter:
    says:

    Nevertheless, It is still a good precedent in you case, even if it can’t be used…

    Abe, please keep us informed regarding your case and that stupid company.

  2. jun
    Twitter:
    says:

    since there are no laws here yet, maybe you can cite this provision and other cases like this. In lieu of a national law, I don’t know if international laws can be used.

    And to the future lawmakers: please pass progressive and timely laws like this.. as well as other ICT enabling laws… such as that of open source (without anti-business provisions).

  3. Fleeb says:

    @Jun,

    They are still busy with the campaigns, so nobody would be noticing that request until the next election >:)

  4. Carlo says:

    Nagaagawan pa sila sa pwesto… pabaitan clang lahat kuno…daming TV ads and radio ads.. kala mo kung sinong mababait at mapagkakatiwalaan… hanef talaga ang politics sa Pinas! La ako masabi.

  5. noemi
    Twitter:
    says:

    we can do something about this by recommending a bill to a senator.

  6. retz says:

    Blogger’s party list
    Abraham Olandres
    for Congress!

  7. Ronnie says:

    The problem right now with our legislators is that, unless something happens that would attract much media attention, they wouldn’t pay attention to it.

    Consider the e-Commerce Law.

    Wasn’t the passing of that law hastened by the effect the I Love You virus had in and out of the country? They couldn’t press charges against the alleged creator of the virus since we don’t have laws regarding cases like those back then.

  8. johnxarce says:

    im an admin of forum i think because of blackhat SEO forum andd blog spamming is abuse by some because do not know about SEO

  9. I will appreciate if you provide more details on this. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

*
*