So here we go, Smart has made a statement regarding the study conducted by NTC about network performance/benchmarks. The statement refutes Globe’s original press release. The full statement is posted below.
We’ll let you interpret the entire story and determine for yourselves who’s telling the truth.
See related stories on “The Empire Strikes Back: NTC says Globe > Smart” and “Original copy of NTC’s Report on Globe vs. Smart“.
YugaTech.com is the largest and longest-running technology site in the Philippines. Originally established in October 2002, the site was transformed into a full-fledged technology platform in 2005.
How to transfer, withdraw money from PayPal to GCash
Prices of Starlink satellite in the Philippines
Install Google GBox to Huawei smartphones
Pag-IBIG MP2 online application
How to check PhilHealth contributions online
How to find your SIM card serial number
Globe, PLDT, Converge, Sky: Unli fiber internet plans compared
10 biggest games in the Google Play Store
LTO periodic medical exam for 10-year licenses
Netflix codes to unlock hidden TV shows, movies
Apple, Asus, Cherry Mobile, Huawei, LG, Nokia, Oppo, Samsung, Sony, Vivo, Xiaomi, Lenovo, Infinix Mobile, Pocophone, Honor, iPhone, OnePlus, Tecno, Realme, HTC, Gionee, Kata, IQ00, Redmi, Razer, CloudFone, Motorola, Panasonic, TCL, Wiko
Best Android smartphones between PHP 20,000 - 25,000
Smartphones under PHP 10,000 in the Philippines
Smartphones under PHP 12K Philippines
Best smartphones for kids under PHP 7,000
Smartphones under PHP 15,000 in the Philippines
Best Android smartphones between PHP 15,000 - 20,000
Smartphones under PHP 20,000 in the Philippines
Most affordable 5G phones in the Philippines under PHP 20K
5G smartphones in the Philippines under PHP 16K
Smartphone pricelist Philippines 2024
Smartphone pricelist Philippines 2023
Smartphone pricelist Philippines 2022
Smartphone pricelist Philippines 2021
Smartphone pricelist Philippines 2020
wha says:
telco war, puro gastos sa advertisement. pareparehas lang naman na UNREALIABLE ang SERVICE. kung un pinambayad nio sa mga FALSE ADVERTISEMENT nio ginamit na pang sa pagpaganda ng SERVICE nio matutuwa pa kami.
Ramon says:
Personally, I think both telcos still have a long way to go to completely satisfy their customers =p
but focusing on the topic, Globe had definitely released their statement with false facts and twisted data to make them look good
Whether it was a mistake by an individual or a deliberate attempt in lying to the public… The damage has been done, and no doubt Smart will take advantage of this fiasco -_-
Gino says:
Well said SMART! Now, that’s really embarrassing of Globe. Especially in the Average Signal Level. Marunong ba kayo bumasa ng -dbm??? Peace :)
magikero says:
we all know that both telco sucks, pero ang tunay na issue dito ay kung sino ang mas nagsasabi ng totoo. malinaw naman ang nakalagay sa NTC report. globe subs here.
coachjojoc says:
Wanna know what this telco war is all about?
De La Salle (the Zobels) vs Ateneo (Pangilinan).
Simple as that.
daniel says:
dont really believe that Smart is less than Globe.
globe is so spotty and weak. smart has the largest expenses in infrastructure upgrades. and most of all… they havent destroyed an old system while upgrading. haha
nexusboy says:
SMART claiming they are the superior network is plain stupidity. how can one claim it is such when 10 out of 100 calls made in Smart are blocked?! Globe’s old network outperformed Smart’s already upgraded network with only 5% of calls failed to go through. This alone can dispute Smart’s claim. and besides, those 4 out of 5 tests, Smart only leads in decimal places therefore insignificant. jeeeez
Abet says:
It’s Telecom against Telecom.This means war! http://kabayantech.com/2012/09/smart-swears-its-signal-five-times-stronger-than-globe/
nexusboy says:
I read a lot of Smart’s print advertisement goin on for quite sometime now that they’re network is now FULLY UPGRADED! while hotting Globe’s upgrading still in progress. NOW that NTC tests reveal Smart has twice as much blocked calls than GLOBE’s legacy network, SMART is now saying they continue to work hard in improving their network. hahaha! who are they fooling? the paid bloggers? what a joke.
Darwin says:
If you’re wondering how Smart came up with the “5x stronger” figure, here’s how:
Average Receive Signal Level (higher is better):
Globe: -69.83 dBm
Smart: -62.63 dBm (BETTER)
Difference: -62.63 dBm – -69.83 dBm = 7.2 dB
That 7.2 dB difference means “higher by a factor of 5.25” or to put in context, “around 5 times stronger.”
For the curious:
7.2 dB = 10*log(X)
X = antilog(7.2/10)
X ~= 5.25
Eizan says:
At least, Smart had the decency to use their domain as an email provider to their PR department unlike GLOBE.corp****@****.***
Iyan Sommerset says:
All I see is corporate dick-waving at each other while ignoring both their customer bases.
edwaine says:
Gawin nalang nila ang mga improvements sa mga system nila kesa nagbabangayan sila ng ganyan diba.
Dangem says:
hays sana people oriented sila hindi yong puro profit lang nasa isip nila.
Dicube says:
this sounds GOOD na merun competition but it will be greater if their are 3 players
huh says:
Smart and Globe are both terrible, lets compare them to the rest of Asia. Japan, Korea, Singapore, thailand the list goes on. You know whats a joke? Hspa+ getting a max of 3mbps if you are lucky in Makati which is supposed to be the business center of the philippines.
What a joke , the lte will just be another joke
The government needs to set standards of what can be considered broadband or 4G. Poor internet here hurts business so much
yogiboy says:
I am a Globe user. Yes they are weak even
in Ayala Center, Makati. Spotty 3G and keeps
on switching bands frequently. Too much
interruption and when finally connected to
3G….no data comes in! All I see is mostly
EDGE signal.
toning says:
walang kwenta pareho…mga sms late dumating.pag ng-txt si misis na pauwi na sya…nauuna pa sya dumarating kesa txt nya…pano na lang kung may lalaki este babae ako sa bahay…eh di huli.
dapat ni-rate nila quality of service or customer satisfaction!
Soul Annihilator says:
No contest here. Both are terrible. Pagandahin na muna nila services nila bago sila magyabang.
Kups says:
Puro outsource na kasi ang gumagawa at nag-uupgrade ng network nila. Kadalasan yung mga taong involved sa network infra nila gaya ng Engineers at technicians, ay puro UNDERPAID kaya most of the time hindi na nagagampanan ng maayos yung tungkulin nila. Ikaw ba naman na halos minimum lang ang basic salary mo at 24/7 ang work mo. Kaya di rin sila makahatak ng magagaling na fresh grad at experienced professionals ay dahil agency na ang hahawak at bukod pa sa sobrang baba ng sahod.
hanjo says:
i agree with the many who says that both of these telcos havea long way to go to meet customers’ demand for better service. they really are disappointing.
Student Observer says:
In my humble opinion, hindi naman intensyon ng Globe (via their press release) na i-misinterpret ang results ng test na ginawa ng NTC. I think what they meant was that, their “Legacy Network” (READ: Old network equipments) is performing in parity with Smart’s widely publicized “Upgraded” (READ: Modernized) network. Globe must have been so proud to learn that their legacy network performed “in parity” and even managed to outperform Smart’s upgraded network in 1 of the 5 test metrics conducted by the NTC.
Yun lang yung nakikita kong gustong i-point out ng Globe. Just my two cents. :)
rakistang_jeff says:
Telco Wars (Globe versus Smart)…mag-focus nga muna kayo na ayusin infrastructure nyo kasya awayan ang inaatupag nyo. Pare-parehas naman kayong unreliable. NTC gising-gising. Mag set naman kayo ng tamang standard sa mga telcong ito at bigyan ng karapatdapat na fine kapag di naibigay sa subscribers yung service. Alam kong di natin puwede maihantulad ang mga telco natin sa ibang bansa. Pero pagdating sa technology nakakasabay naman bansa natin kaso di naman reliable at nakakatawa HSPA+ ang signal pero 300kbps pababa ang nakukuhang speed. Wala din. :(
Telco Stig says:
Hahaha Smart is also trying to divert attention in this statement but not me!! True they are better than Globe’s (old network) in 4 out of 5 criteria. But we must not forget and realize the importance of the CRITERIA NUMBER1: Blocked calls. Para saan pa ang lakas ng signal, ganda ng quality etc.. etc.. Eh kung sa umpisa palang di ka na makatawag!! Blocked calls ang taas ng probability!! Sus naman napakasimple. Kaya naman pala hirap ako makatawag tapos sasabihin upgraded na sila mid2012. Tapos nagpapabango pa sa commercials. Ano ba yan!?! Ayusin nyo naman